Two file suit to restore academic reputations - Beckley, Bluefield & Lewisburg News, Weather, Sports

Two file suit to restore academic reputations

Posted: Updated:
  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Brush Fire Burns on Herndon Mountain

    Brush Fire Burns on Herndon Mountain

    Thursday, April 24 2014 11:09 PM EDT2014-04-25 03:09:30 GMT
    Brush Fire on Herndon Mountain taken by Larry MarrsBrush Fire on Herndon Mountain taken by Larry Marrs
    A large brush fire is burning in Wyoming County Thursday night (4/24). The fire is covering around 160 acres on Herndon Mountain near Garwood and Alpoca.
    A large brush fire is burning in Wyoming County Thursday night (4/24). The fire is covering around 160 acres on Herndon Mountain near Garwood and Alpoca.
  • Gala to be Held for the Restoration of the John Henry Museum and Gift Shop

    Gala to be Held for the Restoration of the John Henry Museum and Gift Shop

    Thursday, April 24 2014 6:53 PM EDT2014-04-24 22:53:29 GMT
    HINTON -- The Hinton Hope Foundation, along with the John Henry Historical Society, are hosting a fundraiser gala on Saturday, May 10 from 5 p.m. to 8 p.m. The proceeds of the event will go towards the renovation of the new John Henry Museum and Gift Shop in Talcott. The gala will be held at the 19th century building, which is the future site of the museum. John Henry memorabilia, historic paintings, and antiques will be up for auction and local bands will provide entertainment.The renovation...
    HINTON -- The Hinton Hope Foundation, along with the John Henry Historical Society, are hosting a fundraiser gala on Saturday, May 10 from 5 p.m. to 8 p.m. The proceeds of the event will go towards the renovation of the new John Henry Museum and Gift Shop in Talcott. The gala will be held at the 19th century building, which is the future site of the museum. John Henry memorabilia, historic paintings, and antiques will be up for auction and local bands will provide entertainment.The renovation...
  • Bud/Alpoca dirty water runs clear, for now?

    Bud/Alpoca dirty water runs clear, for now?

    Thursday, April 24 2014 6:52 PM EDT2014-04-24 22:52:23 GMT
    In Wyoming County, people in Bud and Alpoca have been living without clean water for almost a year.
    In Wyoming County, people in Bud and Alpoca have been living without clean water for almost a year.

A former and a current West Virginia University employee have filed a federal lawsuit saying the university's board of governors and others failed to restore their reputations following an academic integrity investigation that didn't find misconduct. 

Cyril Logar and R. Stephen Sears filed the action May 14 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of West Virginia against the West Virginia University Board of Governors, including members from 2010 through now; Nigel Clark, special academic integrity officer of WVU; Marjorie A. McDiarmid, professor of law and technology and academic integrity officer for WVU; E. Jane Martin, former provost of WVU; James P. Clements, president of WVU; and Michelle Wheatly, provost of WVU.

Logar says he lost his position as an associate dean of the business school and asserts he is now "an outcast in the WVU community."

Meanwhile, Sears says he lost his position at the College of Business and Economics, was denied a merit raise and is having trouble finding another job because of the allegations against him.

"The inquiry dragged on for years, far exceeding the 210-day period provided in plaintiffs' employment contracts with the university and the (academic integrity) policy," the suit states. 

"The investigation — and the negative publicity resulting from WVU's multiple media leaks — destroyed plaintiffs' professional reputations, but concluded with a finding that they had done nothing wrong."

The academic integrity policy, Logar and Sears say in their suit, provides procedure for inquiries into allegations of academic misconduct.

The suit stems from an October 2007 incident when a media outlet contacted WVU about whether then- Gov. Joe Manchin's daughter, Heather Bresch, had earned a master's degree. 

At that time, Sears was the dean of the College of Business and Economics and Logar served as the associate dean of this school.

The suit says four days after this media inquiry, the president's chief of staff called a meeting to review whether she had earned her master's degree.

Sears sent out a letter later that month telling media that she had satisfied the requirements to earn that degree.

The next year, McDiarmid sent letters to Logar, Sears and other people, informing them they were charged with academic misconduct.

Sears and Logar say the hearing panel as established in the academic integrity policy was set to convene beyond the 210-day limit for completion of the investigation.

"And the hearing panel never convened, even on its delayed schedule. The university never presented a case of academic misconduct to a hearing panel. No finding of misconduct was made," the suit asserts.

The suit additionally asserts the university leaked stories to the media that cast Sears and Logar in an unfavorable light.  

"Those leaks — not to mention the years-long duration of the university's investigation — caused serious harm to plaintiffs' reputations," the suit alleges.

Clark, another defendant named in the lawsuit, later found in August 2012 that there were unreasonable delays in the investigations of Sears and Logar, raising due process implications, the suit continues. Clark also said no further academic misconduct action would be taken into the Bresch degree matter.

Sears and Logar said academic integrity proceedings against them were terminated and no academic misconduct was found.

Both want the university to restore their reputations, the suit continues.

According to a past State Journal story, Sears and Logar filed a lawsuit in December 2010, alleging the board of governors violated its own policy and procedures related to academic misconduct proceedings by failing to ensure an impartial investigation.

This suit also stemmed from the Bresch degree matter.

They also said the board of governors denied procedural due process rights because they say there were conflicts of interest in the investigation.

This suit was dismissed, however, because it was filed too late.