Attracting students to teaching takes leadership - Beckley, Bluefield & Lewisburg News, Weather, Sports

Attracting students to teaching takes leadership

Posted: Updated:
Charles McElwee Charles McElwee
  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • UPDATE: Search for suspects in Beckley shooting continues

    UPDATE: Search for suspects in Beckley shooting continues

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 6:38 PM EDT2014-08-27 22:38:57 GMT
    Three people are in the hospital Tuesday night after a shooting along Antonio Avenue in Beckley.Police said around 5 PM two men rushed up to a basketball game on a court near an apartment complex and started firing guns.Three men suffered injuries as a result.The three men were taken to a nearby hospital.Detective Morgan Bragg with Beckley Police said one man was in surgery around 6 PM Tuesday night.The other two men were in stable condition. Surveillance video from a camera near the basketba...
    Three people are in the hospital Tuesday night after a shooting along Antonio Avenue in Beckley.Police said around 5 PM two men rushed up to a basketball game on a court near an apartment complex and started firing guns.Three men suffered injuries as a result.The three men were taken to a nearby hospital.Detective Morgan Bragg with Beckley Police said one man was in surgery around 6 PM Tuesday night.The other two men were in stable condition. Surveillance video from a camera near the basketba...
  • 3rd annual Everett Lilly Memorial Festival to come to Raleigh County

    3rd annual Everett Lilly Memorial Festival to come to Raleigh County

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 6:22 PM EDT2014-08-27 22:22:37 GMT
    The 3rd annual Everett Lilly Memorial Festival is coming soon.You can celebrate the life of one of the forefathers of bluegrass music,while enjoying the live performances by The Lilly Mountaineers,Johnny Cochran, Idletymes and much more.
    The 3rd annual Everett Lilly Memorial Festival is coming soon.You can celebrate the life of one of the forefathers of bluegrass music,while enjoying the live performances by The Lilly Mountaineers,Johnny Cochran, Idletymes and much more.
  • UPDATE: Residents Without A Home Following Fire

    UPDATE: Residents Without A Home Following Fire

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 6:19 PM EDT2014-08-27 22:19:23 GMT
    Residents in a Shady Spring home are displaced after a fire burnt down their home on Tuesday evening.
    Residents in a Shady Spring home are displaced after a fire burnt down their home on Tuesday evening.
  • ColumnsMore>>

  • Advances in technology can be both hazardous, helpful to your health

    Advances in technology can be both hazardous, helpful to your health

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 12:50 PM EDT2014-08-27 16:50:48 GMT
    “Sometimes I think I spend 80 percent of my time undoing what other people tell my patients,” Dr. Bob groaned after I recently asked him if I should increase my daily intake of a certain medicine now in my daily regime.
    “Sometimes I think I spend 80 percent of my time undoing what other people tell my patients,” Dr. Bob groaned after I recently asked him if I should increase my daily intake of a certain medicine now in my daily regime.
  • Understanding the quiet man behind the manic genius

    Understanding the quiet man behind the manic genius

    Tuesday, August 26 2014 6:00 AM EDT2014-08-26 10:00:18 GMT
    I met Robin Williams 32 years ago at a bar in Italy. He must have been about 31 and had lived almost half of his life, although we didn't know it at the time.I was sitting at the bar with my ex-husband.
    I met Robin Williams 32 years ago at a bar in Italy. He must have been about 31 and had lived almost half of his life, although we didn't know it at the time.I was sitting at the bar with my ex-husband.
  • Can creative nonfiction save newspapers?

    Can creative nonfiction save newspapers?

    Tuesday, August 26 2014 6:00 AM EDT2014-08-26 10:00:18 GMT
    Journalists give the essence of the story in the clothesline lead. They have been taught to begin a news story by telling the reader who, what, where, when, why and how. Any good journalist knows what the inverted pyramid is.
    Journalists give the essence of the story in the clothesline lead. They have been taught to begin a news story by telling the reader who, what, where, when, why and how. Any good journalist knows what the inverted pyramid is.

Charles McElwee is a Charleston lawyer with the firm Robinson & McElwee PLLC. The views expressed are his own.

The Education Audit says it not once but twice: "Having effective teachers rises to the top of every study as the most important factor in determining student success" and "National research and best practice clearly shows (sic) that the best predictor of student achievement is effective teachers…." (pp. 117, 122). 

Many commentators agree. Among them: 

Andrew N. Liveris, chairman and CEO, Dow Chemical Co., in his book "Make It In America" ("(T)he most decisive factor in student achievement (is) the quality of the teacher in front of (the classroom)." (p. 149); 

Bill Gates ("(W)hen each of the variables under a school's control is correlated with student achievement, the teacher is the one that makes the biggest difference — and that difference can be dramatic.') Quoted by Liveris, p. 149; 

Thomas L. Friedman and Michael Mandelbaum, "That Used To Be Us" ("The quality of an education system cannot exceed the quality of the teachers," citing a study conducted by McKinsey, p. 111.)

McKinsey & Company, "Closing the talent gap: Attracting and retaining top-third graduates to careers in teaching," (September 2010) ("Research shows that of all the controllable factors influencing student achievement, the most important by far is the effectiveness of the classroom teacher." p. 9.)

According to McKinsey, the U.S. initiatives, unlike the world's top-performing school systems, have sought "to improve the effectiveness of teachers already in the classroom, not to upgrade the caliber of young people entering the profession." p. 9.)

"Top-performing (school systems) such as Singapore, Finland and South Korea have made a different choice (than the United States)." They recruit leading academic talent, "top third students," to teaching careers and then "rigorously screen students on other qualities they believe to be predictors of teaching success." (McKinsey, p. 9.) 

"Prior to 2000, Finland rarely, if ever, appeared on anyone's list of the world's most outstanding education systems." Nine years later, in 2009, its students' reading, math and science performances on PISA that year ranked either second or third among the world's school systems. ("Surpassing Shanghai," Marc S. Tucker, Editor, pp. 51, 76.

(For an excellent survey of the Finnish public-school system, see Pasi Sahlberg, "Finnish Lessons.")

While officials in top-performing countries have little doubt that recruiting teachers from the top third is critical to their success, the story is different in the United States. It "attracts most of its teachers from the bottom two-thirds of college classes, with nearly half coming from the bottom third, especially for schools in poor neighborhoods." McKinsey, p. 12.

Tucker observes that "(o)rganizations that care about the quality of their workforce know that the single most important factor in that calculus is the character of the pool from which it recruits. No private firm, much less an entire industry, would prefer to recruit its professional staff from the least-able college graduates if it could do better than that." (p. 179.)

"The College Board reported in 2008 that when high school graduates going on to college were asked what their intended major was, those who had decided on education scored in the bottom third on their SATs. Their combined scores in mathematics and reading came in at fifty-seven points below the national average." (Tucker, pp. 180-81.)

McKinsey surveyed nearly 1,500 top-third U.S. college students and current teachers and found that when they compared teaching with their preferred occupations, teaching fell short across the board. In an exhibit to its report, McKinsey found that the survey participants who did not plan to teach ranked these three attributes of their preferred occupation most highly and in the following order: "Attracts the type of people I would want to work with;" "I would be proud to tell people I had the job;" and "Would be challenging in a satisfying way." McKinsey, "Attracting and retaining top talent in US teaching," September 2010 article.

Tucker concludes at page 171 that "(n)o (school system) can move the vast majority of students to the levels of intellectual capacity and creativity now demanded (for a workforce in a global economy) unless that (system) is recruiting most of its teachers from the group of young people who are now typically going into the nonfeminized professions."

What will it take for West Virginia to develop the "will" to find a "way" to address in a bold, comprehensive manner fundamental, but long-neglected basics of its public school system, including, as this article suggests, a review of (a) the academic rankings among their immediately preceding scholastic peer group of students enrolling for the first time in, and (b) the academic rankings among their current scholastic peer group (including those who have not chosen to teach), graduating from an approved teacher preparation program in an institution of higher education in the state. 

Again, a reference to McKinsey is in order. It reports that "(w)hile there is no single path to improving school system performance, the experiences of all the 20 improving school systems we studied show that strong commonalities exist in the nature of their journeys." "How the world's most improved school systems keep getting better," (p. 1) by Mona Mourshed and others, November 2010.

According to the cited article, "By far, the most common event to spark the drive to reform is a change in leadership: every system we studied relied upon the presence and energy of a new leader, either political or strategic, to jumpstart their reforms…. (t)hese new leaders tend to follow a consistent ‘playbook' of practices upon entering office to lay the foundations for their improvement journey." (p. 3).

In my view, that "new leadership" in West Virginia resides in its Board of Education (its president and members), as the determiner "of the educational policies of the public schools of the State," and in a newly selected, exemplary state superintendent of schools chosen, based on a vigorous nationwide search, for his/her breadth of knowledge of innovative thinking in public education and of how high-performing school systems have dramatically changed education and improved student outcomes.