Attorneys ask for Marple case dismissal - Beckley, Bluefield & Lewisburg News, Weather, Sports

Attorneys ask for Marple case dismissal

Posted: Updated:
  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Car Fire Investigation in Fayette County

    Car Fire Investigation in Fayette County

    Friday, August 29 2014 5:24 AM EDT2014-08-29 09:24:05 GMT
    A car fire early Friday morning (8/29)is being investigated in Fayette County.
    A car fire early Friday morning (8/29)is being investigated in Fayette County.
  • Pilot confirmed dead in Virginia military jet crash

    Pilot confirmed dead in Virginia military jet crash

    Thursday, August 28 2014 9:58 PM EDT2014-08-29 01:58:58 GMT
    WESTFIELD, Mass. (AP) -Military officials in Massachusetts say they've confirmed that the pilot of an F-15 jet that crashed in remote Virginia mountains was killed.Col. James Keefe says his "thoughts and prayers are with the family" of the pilot, whose identity hasn't been disclosed.The pilot and jet were with the 104th Fighter Wing of the Massachusetts Air National Guard.The F-15 fighter jet crashed in the mountains of western Virginia on Wednesday, shaking residents but causing no injuries ...
    WESTFIELD, Mass. (AP) -Military officials in Massachusetts say they've confirmed that the pilot of an F-15 jet that crashed in remote Virginia mountains was killed.Col. James Keefe says his "thoughts and prayers are with the family" of the pilot, whose identity hasn't been disclosed.The pilot and jet were with the 104th Fighter Wing of the Massachusetts Air National Guard.The F-15 fighter jet crashed in the mountains of western Virginia on Wednesday, shaking residents but causing no injuries ...
  • Police Search for Missing Woman

    Police Search for Missing Woman

    Thursday, August 28 2014 8:23 PM EDT2014-08-29 00:23:19 GMT
    Darlene HatfieldDarlene Hatfield
    The search is on for a missing woman in Bluefield, West Virginia. Officers with the Bluefield Police Department said Darlene Hatfield has been missing since August 15.
    The search is on for a missing woman in Bluefield, West Virginia. Officers with the Bluefield Police Department said Darlene Hatfield has been missing since August 15.

Attorneys for the state Board of Education have asked Kanawha County Circuit Judge James C. Stucky to dismiss a breech of contract complaint filed by former Superintendent of Schools Jorea Marple.

Marple, terminated in November 2012, claims she was unlawfully fired and that members of the Board of Education had secretly plotted to oust her. Her suit, which she recently refiled, names former board president Wade Linger as a co-defendant, and alleges the board violated the open meetings law.

However, J. Victor Flanagan and Linnsey M. Amores of Pullin, Fowler, Flanagan, Brown & Poe, suggested in their petition to dismiss that as a state agency, the Board of Education is immune from prosecution.

They also pointed out Marple was not under contract and actually served at the will and pleasure of board members, consequently a decision by them to terminate her employment was within their discretion.

“That action was part of the board’s constitutionally dervied governmental function,” the motion stated.

Because she was an at-will employee, they said Marple was not entitled to continued employment. They also insist nothing was said that would reflect poorly on Marple or damage her hirability. When pressed for a comment, the motion said Linder pointed only to a “litany of statistics” showing declining student test results in recent years while acknowledging Marple was no more responsible than “governors, legislators, eeducators or board members.”

“The board determined that in order to fix these problems we needed to head in a new direction with new leadership,” he was quoted in the meeting minutes as saying, adding some of the reasons board members perceived a change was needed was that “many board members found no sense of urgency in the department to address some of the issues that have been outlined; when discussing concerns, we often were met with excuses and not actions; too often we were told how things can’t change instead of being offered solutions; when current practices were challenged, we often found people being defensive.”

The board subsequently adopted that statement as its position, the minutes reflected.

Marple had asked U.S. District Judge Thomas Johnston to dismiss her original lawsuit, which did not single Linder out as defendant, without prejudice so she could strip it of federal implications and refile in state court. Johnston granted that motion April 25.